Opinion: Should You Convert Your Classic Cars to EV?

    Scott Newman12 September, 2024

    Electric Porsche 911 Kit

    The answer is obvious, isn’t it? OF COURSE BLOODY NOT! The sounds and smells of internal combustion are an integral part of the classic car ownership experience and replacing that with a box of volts should be actionable by law.

    At least, that’s the initial reaction. As with most things, once the red-hot wave of emotion recedes to reveal the cool sands of logic, you realise there’s more nuance to the question. In truth, the answer is – it depends.

    Electric Porsche 964

    Electric Porsche 964 by Everrati

    The catalyst for this piece was a friend attending Monterey Car Week who sent a picture of a vivid blue Porsche 964 proudly displaying ‘964 EV’ number plates. This I cannot comprehend.

    Likewise, the companies that tear the incredible flat-12 out of a Ferrari Testarossa and replace it with a Tesla drive unit. “Quicker, quieter and more reliable!” they proclaim.

    Electric Ferrari Testarossa

    Electric Ferrari Testarossa by Electric Classic Cars

    Undoubtedly true, and if you took the cheese and sauce out of your favourite pasta dish, it would no doubt be much healthier, but that’s not really the point. Putting the Testarossa’s flat-12 in the Tesla Model S that donated its drive unit would be a laugh, though.

    Classic cars have long since paid the carbon tax associated with their production and are driven so infrequently their nationwide combined annual CO2 emissions wouldn’t even amount to a rounding error.

    So where, then, is the case for the classic electric vehicle? In my opinion, the line in the sand is whether the engine was an integral part of the original car’s appeal. 

    Electric Defender

    Electric Defender by Jaunt Motors Australia

    The engine is the heart and soul of any driver-focused machine and the fact that converting one to electric power makes it faster or handle better is irrelevant. If a classic Porsche 911 owner wanted a faster, better handling 911, they’d buy a newer 911. 

    Electric Porsche 911

    Electric Porsche 911 by Jaunt Motors Australia

    Where classic EV conversions make perfect sense to me is where the engine was, if anything, a hindrance. Would any Morris Minor owner miss the 22kW/54Nm of fury provided by the A-Series? 

    An EV Kombi would no longer be a dak-dak, but it would at least make it up a hill with no problems and never be at risk of overheating. Dare I say it, an electric Rolls-Royce Silver Shadow would be quieter and infinitely less hassle (well, the powertrain bit, anyway).

    Electric Kombi

    Electric Kombi by Electric Classic Cars

    I suspect most people reading this will be anti EV conversions, but I do think there are examples where it makes sense. That said, anyone sticking batteries in a ’67 Mustang deserves a 302ci Windsor at 8000rpm alarm call every day for the rest of their life.

    Scott Newman

    Writer

    Scott Newman is handsome, charming, wise, immensely talented and certainly didn't write this. He has been an automotive journalist since 2010, starting on Unique Cars before a long-term stint as Associate Editor of MOTOR and more recently being the Road Test Editor of Carsales.com.au 

    Scott’s been lucky enough to drive some of the world’s greatest supercars but reckons every car – especially those of past eras – offers its own unique experience, and you can have just as much fun in something that cost $5000 as $500,000. 

    A past rallyist, Scott will happily compete at every opportunity and owned a Nissan R31 Silhouette for more than 15 years. The current steed is a pleasant but plain family SUV. Something to work on.

    More inRetro Rides Originals

    Ford Fairmont Sedan Grand Sport Rally Pack XA

    Top Tips for Buying a Used Ford Falcon/Fairmont XA-XC (1972-79)

    Ford Falcon XA-XC values have improved significantly, but these cars still don’t match the popularity of earlier XW-XY versions. Basic cars still don't generate enough money to justify high-value restorations and can often be stripped for any usable parts.

    Aston Martin DB5

    Rear View: Aston Martin DB5

    The Aston Martin DB5 was built in tiny numbers compared to its contemporary British rival the Jaguar E-Type, but its enduring association with one of the most successful film franchises in history helped propel the luxury grand tourer coupe to cinematic and automotive immortality.

    1939 Skoda Superb 3000 OHV

    Celebrating 90 years of the Škoda Superb

    The Škoda Superb may only be a relatively recent addition to the Australian automotive landscape, having first launched here in 2010, but 2025 marks 90 years since its debut in its homeland, then-Czechoslovakia.

    More inAmerican

    1970 Dodge Challenger R/T Convertible

    Top Tips for Buying a Used Dodge Challenger (1970-73)

    When Chrysler in the US belatedly got around to building a proper Pony Car, it came in two sizes, with different length wheelbases and some of the most powerful production engines ever made. Collectively, they were the Dodge Challenger and Plymouth Barracuda, a feisty duo which offered too little and arrived too late to take full advantage of the relatively short-lived Muscle Car era.

    Spirit of America Sonic I

    Here's your chance to own the first 600mph land speed record car

    In 1965, Craig Breedlove's 'Spirit of America Sonic I' became the first vehicle to cross the 600mph barrier, and now you could have the chance to own it when it goes to auction on February 27, 2025.

    1964 Ford Mustang Coupe

    Rear View: 1964 Ford Mustang

    Demure enough for church-going, racy enough for the dragstrip, and modish enough for the country club, the original Ford Mustang was designed to appeal to young, educated, style-seeking but cost-conscious buyers. Clearly, it nailed the brief.

    Get The Latest

    Sign up for the latest in retro rides, from stories of restoration to community happenings.

    By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.